The graph of concepts, people and works

Drawing the graph…

psychopedia
Legend

Nodes

Relations

At rest every relation is a thin grey line. Its colour shows on hover and in focus.

Article

A Revised Psychopathology of the Psychoses and Psychoneuroses

Ronald Fairbairn · 1941

In this paper, published in the International Journal of Psycho-Analysis in 1941 and later collected in Psychoanalytic Studies of the Personality (1952), Ronald Fairbairn gives the first systematic statement of the object-relations psychopathology he had begun to work out in his study of schizoid states. He argues that Karl Abraham's scheme of libidinal phases, then the standard framework of psychoanalytic psychopathology, mistakes means for ends: the erotogenic zones are channels through which the libido reaches its objects, not the determinants of its aims, and libido is primarily object-seeking rather than pleasure-seeking. In its place he proposes a developmental scheme founded on the quality of dependence on the object. Infantile dependence is marked by primary identification with an object not yet distinguished from the self and by an incorporative, taking attitude centred on the breast; mature dependence is a relationship of giving as well as taking between a self and an object differentiated from it; and between them lies a transitional stage, in which the child is torn between the urge to leave infantile dependence behind and the urge to cling to it. Within infantile dependence Fairbairn places the origin of schizoid states in the early oral phase, where love itself is felt to destroy, and of depressive states in the late oral phase, where hate threatens the loved object. The obsessional, paranoid, hysterical and phobic conditions are not, in his account, fixations at particular libidinal phases but four techniques of the transitional stage, distinguished by whether the accepted and the rejected object are each treated as internal or external, and employed as defences against the more fundamental schizoid and depressive states.

Main ideas

  • Libido is primarily object-seeking rather than pleasure-seeking. The erotogenic zones are channels through which it reaches its objects, not the source of its aims, so it is the relationship to the object that determines the libidinal attitude, not the other way round.
  • Abraham's sequence of libidinal phases is set aside. The oral and genital attitudes are kept as the natural channels of the infantile and the mature relationship, but the anal and phallic 'phases' are treated as artefacts: techniques for dealing with objects rather than stages of development. Genital sexuality follows from mature object relations; it does not create them.
  • Development is classified by the quality of dependence on the object: infantile dependence, a transitional stage, and mature dependence. Fairbairn speaks of mature dependence rather than independence, since a life without need of objects is impossible; what matures is the capacity to relate to an object as a separate person.
  • Infantile dependence rests on primary identification, the cathexis of an object not yet differentiated from the self, and on an incorporative, taking attitude; mature dependence rests on the differentiation of the object and on an attitude of giving.
  • Schizoid states originate in the early, sucking oral phase, before ambivalence, and depressive states in the late, biting oral phase. The schizoid individual's problem is how to love without destroying the object by love, the depressive's how to love without destroying it by hate; these are the two basic forms of psychopathology, and both arise in the stage of infantile dependence.
  • The transitional stage is a conflict between the progressive urge to give up infantile dependence and the regressive urge to keep it, between the anxiety of separation from the object and the fear of being imprisoned or absorbed by it. In it the object is divided into an accepted and a rejected object, each of which may be treated as internal or external.
  • The obsessional, paranoid, hysterical and phobic conditions are four techniques of the transitional stage, defined by where they place the two objects: the obsessional treats both as internal, the phobic both as external, the paranoid keeps the accepted object inside and puts the rejected one outside, and the hysterical does the reverse.
  • The excretory functions supply the model for dealing with the rejected object, which is handled as bodily content to be got rid of: the obsessional conflict takes the form of retaining and expelling contents, while the phobic conflict takes the form of flight from the object and return to it.
  • These techniques are defences against the deeper schizoid and depressive states, not regressions to fixation points. Symptoms are accordingly read as ways of managing relationships with internalised objects, and the paranoid state, classically counted a psychosis, is placed among the transitional techniques alongside the psychoneuroses rather than with the schizoid and depressive states.

What it shows

  • 1941

    Ronald Fairbairn introduced Schizoid position

    Worked out in the papers of 1940 and 1941, where Fairbairn set a schizoid position alongside and beneath Klein's depressive position.
  • Ronald Fairbairn disputed with Karl Abraham

    In the 1941 paper Fairbairn criticised Abraham's scheme of libidinal phases and replaced it with stages defined by the quality of dependence on objects.
  • Melanie Klein influenced Ronald Fairbairn

    Fairbairn built on Klein's ideas of internal objects and the depressive position, while moving away from her reliance on instincts.

In English

Esc

↑ ↓ to move · Enter to go · Esc to close